The meeting of US President Donald Trump and Pakistani Army Chief General Asim Munir at the White House on June 18, 2025 has stirred up the geopolitics of South Asia. This meeting, which took place in the context of recent tensions between India and Pakistan and the Iran-Israel war, is giving rise to different debates in both countries. While Pakistan is considering it as its diplomatic victory, there is an atmosphere of concern and criticism about this meeting in India. Let us analyze the impact of this meeting and the reasons behind it on the basis of facts.
Background and context of the meeting
This meeting of Pakistani Army Chief Asim Munir took place after the four-day military conflict between India and Pakistan in May 2025, which India launched under "Operation Sindoor" to destroy terrorist bases in Pakistan and PoK. After this conflict, a ceasefire took place between the two countries on May 10. Trump claimed that this ceasefire was possible due to his mediation, but India's Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri rejected this claim and said that it was the result of talks between the Indian and Pakistani armies.
The timing of the meeting is also important, as it took place amid growing tensions between Iran and Israel. Analysts believe that through this meeting, Trump wants to prepare Pakistan for strategic cooperation against Iran, because Pakistan's 900 km border with Iran and the strategic importance of Balochistan make it important in regional diplomacy.
Excitement in Pakistan, concern in India
This meeting is being seen as a diplomatic victory in Pakistan. According to Pakistani newspaper Dawn, this meeting was the result of many months of unconventional efforts, in which advisors and influential people played a role instead of diplomatic channels. In Islamabad, this is being considered the beginning of a new era in US-Pakistan relations. Former Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari called this meeting a positive step for bilateral relations.
Pakistani Army Chief Munir recommended Trump to nominate him for the Nobel Peace Prize for preventing a "nuclear war" between India and Pakistan, which was confirmed by White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly. This statement further strengthened Munir's image in Pakistan, especially when he is facing an economic crisis and opposition from Imran Khan supporters.
On the other hand, this meeting has raised many questions in India. Congress leader Jairam Ramesh termed it a failure of Indian diplomacy and said that giving honor to Munir, whose statements are believed to be related to the Pahalgam terror attack (22 April 2025), at the White House is a "triple blow" for India. The Indian government rejected Trump's claim of mediation and made it clear that it does not accept any third-party mediation.
Experts in India believe that Trump's move could harm India-US relations, especially when India is considered a strategic partner of the US. Some analysts say Trump's meeting is an attempt to make Pakistan a strategic ally against Iran, which may include plans to set up military bases in Pakistan.
Iran-Israel war angle
During the meeting, Trump and Munir also discussed the Iran-Israel conflict. Trump said Pakistan "knows Iran very well" and can play an important role in this context. However, Pakistan condemned Israel's attacks on Iran and appealed to Muslim countries to unite. An Iranian general's claim that Pakistan had promised to use nuclear weapons against Israel was rejected by Pakistani Defence Minister Khawaja Asif.
Pakistan's dual policy—openly supporting Iran and behind-the-scenes cooperation with the US—reflects its complex geopolitical situation. India is concerned that Pakistan may strengthen its military and diplomatic position with US help, which could pose a threat to India.
The centre of the India-Pakistan debate
The centre of the debate in India is whether Trump's move signals a change in the US' South Asia policy or is it merely a strategic move in the context of the Iran-Israel war. Indian users on social media criticised Trump's "love Pakistan" statement and called it a betrayal of India.
In Pakistan, Munir's meeting is being seen as a boost to the army's credibility and a reply to Imran Khan supporters. However, PTI supporters accused Munir of meeting the Israeli lobby and called it against Pakistan's traditional policy.
Conclusion
The meeting of Asim Munir and Donald Trump has generated different emotions and debates in India and Pakistan. While Pakistan is considering it as its diplomatic victory, India is seeing it as a change in US policy and a threat to its security. The long-term effects of this meeting will depend on the Iran-Israel war and the future of India-Pakistan relations.
No comments: